Car negotiation tips

Check Engine Light On? What It Could Mean and What to Do Before You Buy

December 11, 20243 min read

"The check engine light isn’t a suggestion—it’s your car whispering, 'Help me, I’m could be dying inside.'" — Chase Jordan - Ask me how I know! :)

Check Engine Light On? What It Could Mean and What to Do Before You Buy


🚨 Don’t Ignore the Glow

You're checking out a used car, everything seems great… until that little amber icon lights up: Check Engine.

For many buyers, it’s an immediate dealbreaker—or worse, something they overlook in excitement.

But understanding what this light means and how to handle it can make or break your deal.

Here’s what you need to know before buying a car with an active (or recently cleared) check engine light.


🔧 What the Check Engine Light Actually Means

The Check Engine Light (CEL) is part of your vehicle’s OBD-II (On-Board Diagnostics) system.

When it lights up, the system has detected a problem—anything from minor to catastrophic.

Here’s a breakdown of what it might mean:

Common (Minor) Triggers:

  • Loose gas cap

  • Low-grade fuel

  • Faulty oxygen sensor

  • Small evap leak

Moderate Concerns:

  • Failing catalytic converter

  • Misfiring spark plugs

  • Faulty mass airflow sensor

Big Red Flags:

  • Transmission trouble

  • Engine timing issues

  • Emissions system failure

⚠️ Important: If the light is flashing, it signals a misfire that could damage the engine. Do not drive far.


🔍 What You Should Do When You See It

1. Ask for a Diagnostic Code Report

  • Every dealership or seller should provide a free OBD-II scan.

  • Get the codes in writing or photo.

  • Look up the code (e.g., P0420 = catalytic converter efficiency).

2. Bring Your Own Scanner (or Use AutoZone)

  • Basic code readers cost $20–$40.

  • Auto parts stores like AutoZone will scan for free.

3. Watch for Cleared Codes

  • If the seller “just reset it,” be skeptical.

  • A freshly reset system might be hiding bigger problems that haven’t re-triggered yet.

  • Always test drive 15+ minutes after a reset to see if it returns.

4. Get an Independent Inspection

  • A mechanic can pull deeper “pending codes.”

  • They’ll also inspect related systems the code points to.


❌ Common Mistakes Buyers Make

  • Believing “it’s just the gas cap” without confirming

  • Buying without a scan or mechanic review

  • Assuming a recent oil change or tune-up “solved the problem”

  • Thinking the car passes emissions = all is well (not always true)


🛡️ How Deal Guard Handles Check Engine Lights

At Deal Guard—the most trusted car buying concierge—we treat every CEL as a potential deal changer.

We:

  • Require a full OBD-II report before any deal closes

  • Investigate the service history for recurring CELs

  • Use professional inspectors to verify fixes

  • Advise if it’s something minor, negotiable, or worth walking away from

You’ll never have to guess if that little light is a little problem—or a big wallet bomb.

👉 See how we protect buyers from surprise repairs


⚡️ Final Takeaway

The check engine light isn’t a mystery—it’s a message.

Learn what it’s saying, use the right tools, and never ignore it because “everything else looks good.”

With Deal Guard in your corner, you’ll always know whether to move forward—or move on.

That’s why we’re the most trusted name in car buying.


Go to GETDEALGUARD.COM to see how we’re helping people across the U.S. and Canada buy cars the smart way!

Tired of the hassle?

We handle everything—so you don’t have to.

Our trusted car buying concierge service locks in every detail, protects your time and money, and—most importantly—saves your sanity.

No stress. No pressure. No regrets.

We help you avoid bad deals and wasted hours.

Your time matters—let’s protect it together.

Ready to make buying a car actually fun?

Check out FUNNEWCAR.COM and discover how we turn car shopping into something as sweet as your favorite dessert.

Maybe even sweeter.

See you soon,
Chase Jordan

Back to Blog